Beaujolais & Business: Can a Handshake Deal Really Create a Binding Contract? - Berry Smith

Beaujolais & Business: Can a Handshake Deal Really Create a Binding Contract?

Every November, businesses across South Wales dust off their smart-casual attire, put the out-of-office on, and head out to celebrate Beaujolais Day. For many, it is an opportunity to catch up with clients, strengthen business relationships and, perhaps, make a few new connections over a glass of Beaujolais Nouveau.

It is also a day when business conversations can turn into business opportunities. A discussion over lunch might lead to a new supplier arrangement, a promising collaboration, or even the beginnings of a significant commercial deal.

But what happens when a conversation ends with a handshake and a promise to get things moving? Is that handshake enough to create a legally binding contract?

The short answer is yes. Under the law of England and Wales, a contract does not necessarily need to be written down, signed, or witnessed to be legally enforceable.

A deal is a deal – or is it?

There is a common misconception that a contract only becomes legally binding once everyone has signed a formal agreement. In reality, English contract law takes a more flexible approach.

A contract can be formed through spoken words, written correspondence, emails or the conduct of the parties. In most commercial situations, the courts will look at what the parties said and did, rather than simply whether a document was signed.

Generally, four key elements need to be present:

1. Offer and acceptance: One party must make a sufficiently clear offer, which the other party accepts.

2. Consideration: Something of value must be exchanged between the parties. This is often payment in return for goods or services, but can also include a promise to do something.

3. Intention to create legal relations: The parties must intend their agreement to have legal consequences.

4. Certainty of terms: The agreement must be sufficiently clear and complete for the parties’ respective obligations to be understood and enforced.

In a commercial setting, there is generally a presumption that parties intend to create legally binding relationships. This means that a business owner who agrees a deal with another business owner over lunch may find themselves contractually committed, even if neither has put pen to paper.

When a handshake goes wrong

A relevant example is the 2017 case of Blue v Ashley.

The dispute arose from an alleged conversation in a pub between a businessman, Mr Blue, and Mike Ashley, the founder of Sports Direct. Mr Blue claimed that Mr Ashley had promised him £15 million if he could increase Sports Direct’s share price to £8.

Despite the extraordinary sum involved, the conversation had taken place informally over drinks. Mr Blue subsequently sought to enforce the alleged promise.

The High Court ultimately dismissed his claim. The judge concluded that, viewed objectively and in the context of the conversation, Mr Ashley’s alleged statement was not intended to create a legally binding obligation.

The case is a useful reminder that not every promise made in a commercial setting will amount to a contract. The surrounding circumstances, the language used and the parties’ intentions all matter.

Importantly, however, Blue v Ashley does not mean that informal business agreements are unenforceable. Quite the opposite: it demonstrates why businesses should be careful about what they say and agree, even in an informal setting.

The real risk: proving what was agreed

For SMEs, the biggest concern with handshake agreements is often not whether a contract exists, but whether its terms can be established if something goes wrong.

Imagine a business owner agreeing with a new supplier to provide 500 units of a product at an agreed price. Both parties shake hands and agree to proceed. However, they never discuss delivery dates, product specifications, or what happens if the goods are defective.

If a dispute subsequently arises, establishing precisely what was agreed can become difficult. Each party may have a different recollection of the conversation and there may be little evidence to support either version.

Even where a contract is legally binding, uncertainty over its terms can make enforcement considerably more complicated.

A short email confirming the key points of a conversation can make a significant difference. It creates a contemporaneous record of what was discussed and gives the other party an opportunity to correct any misunderstandings before work begins.

Three things to remember before raising a glass

· Be clear about what you are agreeing. Make sure the key commercial terms, including price, scope, timescales and responsibilities, are understood by everyone involved.

· Put it in writing. Follow up verbal discussions with an email setting out what has been agreed. For more significant arrangements, use a properly drafted contract.

· Know when to seek legal advice. Larger or more complex arrangements can involve issues around intellectual property, confidentiality, liability, termination and payment terms. These are much easier to address before a deal is agreed than after a dispute arises.

It is also worth remembering that certain types of agreement are subject to specific legal formalities, meaning a handshake or informal exchange will not always be sufficient.